Skip to Content

9 Best Pumping Bras: As Voted By 238 Pumping Moms (2024)

By: Author Lisa Williams, LEC

Posted on Last updated:

Categories Pumps & Gear

9 Best Pumping Bras: As Voted By 238 Pumping Moms (2024)
This post may contain affiliate links. I may receive commissions for purchases made through links on this post (at no extra cost to you).

When you are deciding on the best pumping bra, it can be a challenge. There are lots of lists of the best pumping bras, but it can be difficult to know which bra will work for you. Some pumping bras work better for larger breasts, and some work better for small breasts.

It is also a challenge to find a pumping bra that you can wear all day long, and a pumping bra that you can wear to work.

You may have tried a pumping bra only to find out that it doesn’t work with the flanges on your Spectra or Medela pump.

I surveyed 238 moms to find out their favorite pumping bras for every situation, and here are the results.

Best Pumping Bra To Wear All Day

Kindred Bravely

Best Pumping Bra For Work

Bravado Attachment

and Simply Sublime bra

Best Pumping Bra For Pumping And Nursing

Simple Wishes Super Mom

Best Pumping Bra For A Spectra Pump

Pump Strap

Best Pumping Bra For A Medela Pump

Medela Easy Expressions Bustier

Best Pumping Bra For Plus Size

Pacasso Pumping Bra

Best Pumping Bra For Large Breasts

Simple Wishes Bustier

Best Pumping Bra For Small Breasts

Simple Wishes Bustier

Best Pumping Bra With Underwire

Dairy Fairy Ayla

Below are all the details about what the moms liked and disliked about each of these bras to help you decide on the best bra for you!

This post contains affiliate links, which means I receive a small commission at no additional cost to you.

1. Best Pumping Bra To Wear All Day

One type of pumping bra you may be looking for is one that you can wear all day. This can be a challenge because some pumping bras are slightly uncomfortable when you are not actually using them for pumping.

They can become uncomfortable because many pumping bras have slits or holes in them. These slits allow the pump flanges to be held up against your breasts.

The problem is when you are not pumping, then you do not need these slits and holes in the pumping bra.

91 moms responded to this question in the survey and here are the bras they voted as their top choices for pumping bras to wear all day long:

The best pumping bra to wear all day is this Kindred Bravely pumping bra. It is high quality and comfortable to wear all day long. Many moms mentioned that it has lasted them pumping for multiple children.

Another popular pumping bra is the Rumina bra. This one is less expensive but does not last quite as long.

It is a crossover style, and it can be pulled to the side when you are ready to start pumping. The crossover style makes it very comfortable to wear when you are lounging around the house.

When you are wearing the Rumina bra all day long, you won’t get irritated by holes in the fabric. The biggest benefit is that you do not need to take this bra off and on when it is time to pump.

The Best Pumping Bra To Wear All Day: this Kindred Bravely Bra (link to store).

You can also read more about the best pumping bra to wear all day in my detailed article here.

If you are looking for a pumping bra that works well when you leave the house, you may want to check out the Simple Wishes Super Mom bras.

This bra is more like a traditional bra and has more structure to it, so you can feel more support when wearing it.

2. Best Pumping Bra for Work

The Bravado nursing and pumping bra is the best pumping bra to wear for work (by far). This is actually an attachment that hooks into a normal nursing bra. So, you will need a nursing bra and the bravado attachment in order to pump hands-free with this setup.

You will want to pair the Bravado attachment with a comfortable nursing bra like the Kindred Bravely Simply Sublime nursing bra. This nursing bra gets rave reviews because it is super soft and gives great support. There are also pads to help give you a smooth look under shirts.

The Bravado is great for wearing at work because at work you will want a bra that is fast to take on and off. You will also need one that looks smooth under most shirts and does not look lumpy.

By wearing a nursing bra like the Kindred Bravely, this gives you a great setup: support, comfort, and smooth lines. When it’s time to start pumping, you can quickly unhook the nursing bra and clip in the Bravado attachment to pump hands free.

The Best Pumping Bra For Work: the Bravado Attachment and the Kindred Bravely Simply Sublime Nursing Bra (link to store).

3. Best Bra for Pumping and Nursing

The Simple Wishes Super Mom bra is the most popular bra for pumping and nursing. This bra looks more like a normal bra than a pumping bra.

It is not bulky, so you can wear it under most shirts without seeing strange bumps that you may see with the other bras.

Here are some of the best parts about the Simple Wishes Super Mom bra:

  • It provides support without an underwire.
  • It does gives you a good shape and does not look like a sports bra.
  • The double function of being able to nurse and pump while wearing this bra is super convenient.
  • You can wear this bra comfortably all day long without needing to pull on a separate pumping bustier on top of a nursing bra.

The Best Bra For Pumping And Nursing: the Simple Wishes Super Mom pumping bra (link to Amazon).

4. Best Pumping Bra for Spectra Pumps

To find a hands free pumping bra for a Spectra pump, like the popular Spectra S2 and Spectra S1 pumps, there are a few different challenges.

The Spectra pump comes with accessories and has a one-piece flange (as opposed to Medela’s breast shield and connector that come in two pieces.

This makes things a little more challenging because you cannot use a pumping bra that has a hole for the flange. There isn’t any way to slip your Spectra flange into the bra unless there are folds in the fabric, and certain bras will not work with this setup.

You need to find a pumping bra that is compatible with a Spectra pump.

Here are the top four best pumping bras for a Spectra pump, so you can pump hands free:

The Pump Strap is the bra that works best for a Spectra pump. The slits are wide enough that the one-piece flanges for Spectra can be slipped in after your pumping bra has been pulled up.

Some reasons why moms from the survey loved the Pump Strap are:

  • This bra has a lot of compression and will hold the flanges securely while you are pumping
  • It is easily adjustable, so you can loosen it when you are more engorged and tighten it if you lose weight over time.
  • The Pump Strap leaves enough of your breast exposed so you can massage while pumping
  • It comes in a lot of fun colors

The Best Pumping Bra For Spectra Pumps: the Pump Strap (link to Amazon).

Here are all the details on my personal favorite – the best hands free pumping bra for a Spectra pump.

5. Best Pumping Bra for Medela Pumps

Exclusively pumping moms voted on their favorite pumping bra to use with a Medela pump. The best hands-free pumping bra for Medela pumps was voted to be the Medela Easy Expressions Busier, followed closely by the Rumina bra.

One of the reasons the Medela Easy Expressions Bustier is the best pumping bra for Medela pumps is because it is stretchy. The bra has good compression and will securely hold the flanges against your skin, so you can pump hands free.

Something to remember with this bra is that you will need to put the flanges on and slip them through the holes in the bra before fully zipping it up. Then, you can attach the flanges to the connectors and continue pumping.

The Best Pumping Bra For Medela Pumps: Medela Easy Expressions Bustier (link to Amazon).

6. Best Pumping Bra for Plus Size Moms

The top three pumping bras for plus size moms all had great reviews. The one with the most votes was the Pacasso bra, followed closely by the Bravado Maternity bra with Bravado attachment.

The most comfortable pumping bra for plus size moms is the Pacasso bra, according to the survey. This pumping bra fits up to a 48J, according to their size chart.

The Pacasso bra has adjustable velcro in the back, so you can customize the fit to your body. Then, once you’ve found the perfect fit, you can leave it and use the zipper in the front of the bra to put it on and take it off.

If your body changes over the course of your pumping journey, you can always adjust the velcro so you have a perfect fit.

The Best Pumping Bra For Plus Size Moms: The Pacasso Pumping Bra (link to Amazon).

Another option for plus size moms is to use a maternity bra like the one from Bravado, and then add the bravado attachment for pumping.

This can be a good alternative because the maternity bras come in more sizes than pumping bras. This may end up being more comfortable for you than a bra that is strictly designed for pumping.

The Bravado maternity bra fits up to a 46G according to their size chart. You can wear this bra throughout the day. When you are ready to pump, you can just clip in the Bravado attachment.

This may be a great alternative if you are looking for a pumping bra that you do not have to take on and off throughout the day.

7. Best Pumping Bra for Large Breasts

In the survey, 52 moms voted for their favorite pumping bras for large breasts. Many moms are in search of a hands-free pumping bra that would work for them. The top pumping bras for moms with large breasts are:

The Simple Wishes Bustier was voted as the favorite pumping bra for moms with large breasts. One of the best benefits to this pumping bra is that it is super customizable.

I own this bra, and I love that you can adjust the velcro so it fits you exactly. There is not any worry about buying the wrong size, like when you buy regular bras. It can be worn as a bandeau, and there are also shoulder straps for extra support.

The Best Pumping Bra For Large Breasts: the Simple Wishes Bustier (link to Amazon).

The only downside is that the Simple Wishes busier is not a bra that is comfortable to wear all day. If you are looking for one that is, check out the Bravado attachment that clips into a normal maternity bra. This was also highly rated by the moms in the survey.

When using the Bravado attachment, a good choice is to pair it with the Kindred Bravely Simply Sublime nursing bra. This bra is super comfortable and fits sizes from a B cup to an I cup.

8. Best Pumping Bra for Small Breasts

When searching for a pumping bra for small breasts, there are some unique challenges. You need to make sure that the bra has enough compression to keep the flanges against your chest so you have a comfortable pumping session.

The same pumping bra that was voted the best for large breasts was also voted as the favorite pumping bra for small breasts – the Simple Wishes bustier. This is because this bra is so customizable, it can be tightened to fit a mom with a smaller chest.

The Best Pumping Bra for Small Breasts: the Simple Wishes Bustier (link to Amazon).

If you are looking for a pumping bra that works for a small chest and is also comfortable to wear all day, the Rumina bra was also very highly rated in the survey. One of the best things about the Rumina bra is that you do not have to pull it on and off when you are ready to pump.

Here is a link to the Rumina Pumping Bra (at Amazon).

9. Best Pumping Bra With Underwire

It can be tough to find a good pumping bra that also has an underwire. If you are looking for a hands-free pumping bra that also includes an underwire, here are the top three options:

The top-rated pumping bra with underwire is the Dairy Fairy Ayla. This is a very pretty bra with lace that looks like normal lingerie, and definitely does not look like a pumping bra!

Another advantage to the Dairy Fairy bra is that it is a bra you can wear all day long, so you do not need to pull on another bra when it is time to pump.

The Best Pumping Bra With Underwire: the pretty lace Dairy Fairy underwire pumping bra (link to Amazon).

Your other top-rated options for a pumping bra with underwire is to use:

  • The Cake nursing bra and Bravado attachment, or
  • The Motherhood Maternity Nursing bra with the Bravado attachment for pumping.

Click here to read the reviews for the Cake nursing bra (link to Amazon).

Check out the reviews for the Motherhood Maternity bra here (link to Amazon)

Conclusion

I hope that you have been able to find the perfect pumping bra for you, based on the best pumping bras from the survey!

Something else to keep in mind is that if you ever feel that your nipples are sensitive, you can try slipping a nursing pad between your skin and the bra.

The nursing pads can provide an extra layer of protection between your skin and the bra when you’re not pumping.

You can check out my favorite reusable nursing pads here. These nursing pads are the ones I used during my pumping journey.

More Pumping Tips

If you found this article useful, be sure to save this article to your Pumping board on Pinterest for later.

Follow PumpingMamas on Pinterest for more amazing pumping tips!

Recommended Reading

Check out these great articles for more pumping information:

  1. The Crazy Amount of Calories You Burn Breastfeeding (Or Pumping)
  2. The Ultimate Guide To A Spectra Pump
  3. Replacing Pump Parts: The Secret To Pump Maximum Milk
What's the Best Pumping Bra For You? Includes the best pumping bras to wear all day, for work, for pumping and nursing, for plus size moms, for large breasts and for small breasts.

Sharing is caring!